Probing the Nuclear Force
Nucleon-nucleon (NN) scattering experiments are the primary source of information about the nuclear force. By measuring differential cross sections and polarization observables at various energies, one extracts the NN phase shifts, which encode the strength and range of the interaction in each partial wave channel.
The NN system has four scattering channels: $pp$, $nn$,$np$ (with $T=1$), and $np$ (with $T=0$). The $np$ system accesses both isospin channels, making it especially rich. High-precision NN potentials (Argonne $v_{18}$, CD-Bonn, Nijmegen) fit the world database of over 4000 $pp$ and $np$ scattering data points with$\chi^2/\text{datum} \approx 1$.
Partial Wave Analysis
In the center-of-mass frame, the scattering amplitude for spinless particles is expanded in partial waves:
For nucleons with spin, we use the spectroscopic notation $^{2S+1}L_J$ where$S$ is the total spin, $L$ is the orbital angular momentum, and $J$ is the total angular momentum. The generalized Pauli principle (antisymmetry under exchange of identical fermions) constrains the allowed states:
This means:
Singlet ($S=0$), even $L$: $T=1$
States: $^1S_0$, $^1D_2$, $^1G_4$, ... These exist in $pp$, $nn$, and $np$ ($T=1$).
Singlet ($S=0$), odd $L$: $T=0$
States: $^1P_1$, $^1F_3$, ... These exist only in $np$ ($T=0$).
Triplet ($S=1$), even $L$: $T=0$
States: $^3S_1\text{--}^3D_1$, $^3D_2$, ... The tensor force couples $L$ and $L+2$ when $S=1$. The deuteron lives in the coupled $^3S_1\text{--}^3D_1$ channel.
Triplet ($S=1$), odd $L$: $T=1$
States: $^3P_0$, $^3P_1$, $^3P_2\text{--}^3F_2$, ... These exist in all NN channels.
Effective Range Expansion
At low energies, the S-wave ($\ell = 0$) phase shift dominates and can be parameterized model-independently using the effective range expansion (ERE):
where $a$ is the scattering length, $r_0$ is the effective range, and$P$ is the shape parameter. The scattering length has a geometric interpretation: it is the intercept of the asymptotic wave function with the $r$-axis.
Scattering Length Sign Convention
$a > 0$: The potential supports a bound state near threshold. For the $^3S_1$ channel, $a_t = +5.424$ fm (deuteron exists).
$a < 0$: No bound state, but the potential is nearly strong enough to bind. For the $^1S_0$ channel, $a_s = -23.714$ fm (virtual state very close to threshold).
$|a| \to \infty$: Unitarity limit. A new bound state is forming at zero energy. The $^1S_0$ np system is remarkably close to this with $|a_s| \gg r_0$.
The low-energy np total cross section is given by:
The factor of 3 for the triplet reflects the spin statistical weight ($2S+1 = 3$ for $S=1$ vs 1 for $S=0$).
Charge Independence and Charge Symmetry
Two related symmetries constrain the nuclear force:
Charge Symmetry (CS)
The nuclear force is invariant under interchange of protons and neutrons (rotation by$\pi$ about the 2-axis in isospin space). This implies $V_{pp} = V_{nn}$ in corresponding states. Evidence: the $^1S_0$ scattering lengths are:
After Coulomb correction, the nuclear part of $a_{pp}$ becomes $a_{pp}^N \approx -17.3$ fm, in reasonable agreement with $a_{nn}$. Charge symmetry is broken at the$\sim 1\text{--}3\%$ level by electromagnetic effects and quark mass differences ($m_d - m_u$).
Charge Independence (CI)
The nuclear force is the same in all $T=1$ states regardless of $T_z$:$V_{pp} = V_{nn} = V_{np}^{(T=1)}$. This is a stronger condition than CS. The $^1S_0$ scattering lengths provide a test:
Charge independence is broken at a larger level ($\sim 5\%$ in the potential), primarily by pion mass differences ($m_{\pi^\pm} \neq m_{\pi^0}$) which affect one-pion exchange.
Yukawa Potential and One-Pion Exchange
Hideki Yukawa (1935) proposed that the nuclear force is mediated by the exchange of massive bosons, leading to a potential of the form:
The range of the force is set by the Compton wavelength of the exchanged meson:$\lambda = \hbar/(m_\text{meson}c)$. For the pion ($m_\pi \approx 140$ MeV),$\lambda_\pi = \hbar c/m_\pi c^2 \approx 1.4$ fm, consistent with the observed range of the nuclear force.
The one-pion exchange potential (OPEP) in coordinate space is:
where $x = m_\pi r / \hbar$ and $f_{\pi NN}^2/(4\pi) \approx 0.08$ is the pion-nucleon coupling constant. The OPEP contains both a central spin-spin term and a tensor term $S_{12}$. The tensor component is responsible for the D-state admixture in the deuteron.
Multi-Meson Exchange: Building the Full Potential
The NN potential at different distance scales is dominated by different meson exchanges:
- Long range ($r > 2$ fm): One-pion exchange (OPEP), well established
- Medium range ($1 < r < 2$ fm): Two-pion exchange and scalar $\sigma$ meson, provides main attraction
- Short range ($r < 1$ fm): Vector meson ($\omega, \rho$) exchange, provides repulsive core
- Very short range ($r < 0.5$ fm): Quark-gluon degrees of freedom become relevant
Properties of the Nuclear Force
Decades of scattering experiments have established the following properties of the nuclear force:
1. Short Range
The nuclear force is negligible beyond $r \approx 2\text{--}3$ fm. This is reflected in the exponential falloff of the Yukawa potential and the saturation of nuclear binding energy. Each nucleon interacts only with its nearest neighbors.
2. Repulsive Core
At distances $r \lesssim 0.5$ fm, the nuclear force becomes strongly repulsive. Evidence comes from the high-energy S-wave phase shift passing through zero and becoming negative. The repulsive core prevents nuclear collapse and is essential for nuclear saturation. In modern NN potentials, the core height is $\sim 1$--2 GeV.
3. Spin Dependence
The force depends on the total spin $S$: the $^3S_1$ (triplet) potential is stronger than $^1S_0$ (singlet), as evidenced by the deuteron existing only in the triplet channel. The spin-orbit force $V_{LS}(r)\,\mathbf{L}\cdot\mathbf{S}$ is also significant, as shown by P-wave splitting ($^3P_0$, $^3P_1$, $^3P_2$ have different phase shifts).
4. Tensor Component
The tensor force $V_T(r)\,S_{12}$ is a non-central force that couples orbital and spin angular momenta. It arises naturally from one-pion exchange and is essential for understanding the deuteron quadrupole moment and the D-state admixture. The tensor force mixes partial waves with $\Delta L = 2$.
5. Approximate Charge Independence
The strong interaction is approximately the same for $pp$, $nn$, and $np$in the same isospin state. This isospin symmetry follows from the approximate$u$-$d$ quark mass degeneracy and is broken at the few-percent level.
Python Simulation: Phase Shifts and Cross Sections
Computes S-wave phase shifts from square well and effective range expansion models, meson exchange potentials, and total np cross sections showing triplet and singlet contributions.
NN Scattering Phase Shifts
PythonPhase shifts, meson exchange potentials, and np cross sections
Click Run to execute the Python code
Code will be executed with Python 3 on the server
Fortran Implementation: Scattering Analysis
Tabulates effective range parameters, tests charge independence, connects to the deuteron bound state, and computes phase shifts at multiple energies.
NN Scattering Calculator
FortranEffective range analysis, charge independence tests, and phase shift tables
Click Run to execute the Fortran code
Code will be compiled with gfortran and executed on the server