Biochemistry/Part II: Enzymes/Enzyme Catalysis & Mechanisms

5. Enzyme Catalysis & Mechanisms

Reading time: ~50 minutes | Topics: Catalytic strategies, transition state theory, active site chemistry, serine proteases, cofactors & coenzymes

What Are Enzymes?

Enzymes are biological catalysts that accelerate chemical reactions without being consumed in the process. The vast majority of enzymes are proteins, although a small but important class of catalytic RNA molecules (called ribozymes) also exist. Enzymes are remarkable for their extraordinary catalytic power, high specificity, and capacity for regulation.

Key Properties of Enzymes

  • Rate enhancement: Enzymes accelerate reactions by factors of $10^6$ to $10^{17}$ compared to the uncatalyzed rate.
  • Specificity: Each enzyme acts on a particular substrate or class of substrates with stereochemical precision.
  • Mild conditions: Enzymes operate at physiological temperature, pressure, and near-neutral pH.
  • Regulation: Enzyme activity can be modulated by allosteric effectors, covalent modification, and gene expression.

Crucially, enzymes lower the activation energy ($\Delta G^\ddagger$) of a reaction without altering the overall free energy change ($\Delta G$) or the equilibrium constant ($K_\text{eq}$). They accelerate both the forward and reverse reactions equally, reaching equilibrium faster but not shifting it.

Enzyme Classification (EC Numbering)

The Enzyme Commission (EC) classifies enzymes into six major classes based on the type of reaction catalyzed:

EC ClassNameReaction TypeExample
EC 1OxidoreductasesOxidation-reductionLactate dehydrogenase
EC 2TransferasesGroup transferHexokinase
EC 3HydrolasesHydrolysisChymotrypsin
EC 4LyasesNon-hydrolytic cleavageAldolase
EC 5IsomerasesIsomerizationTriose phosphate isomerase
EC 6LigasesBond formation (ATP-dependent)Pyruvate carboxylase

Each enzyme receives a four-part EC number (e.g., EC 3.4.21.1 for chymotrypsin), specifying class, subclass, sub-subclass, and serial number.

Transition State Theory

The rate of a chemical reaction depends on the energy barrier separating reactants from products. The transition state (denoted $\ddagger$) represents the highest-energy species along the reaction coordinate. Enzymes work by preferentially stabilizing this transition state, thereby lowering the activation energy.

The Arrhenius Equation

The empirical relationship between rate constant and temperature:

$$k = A \, e^{-E_a / RT}$$

where $A$ is the pre-exponential (frequency) factor, $E_a$ is the activation energy,$R$ is the gas constant, and $T$ is absolute temperature.

The Eyring Equation

Transition state theory provides a more fundamental description. The Eyring equation relates the rate constant to the free energy of activation:

$$k = \frac{k_B T}{h} \, e^{-\Delta G^\ddagger / RT}$$

where $k_B$ is the Boltzmann constant and $h$ is Planck's constant. The activation free energy decomposes into enthalpic and entropic contributions:

$$\Delta G^\ddagger = \Delta H^\ddagger - T \Delta S^\ddagger$$

How Enzymes Lower $\Delta G^\ddagger$

An enzyme binds the transition state with greater affinity than the substrate. If the enzyme stabilizes the transition state by $\delta(\Delta G^\ddagger) = -50$ kJ/mol, the rate enhancement is:

$$\frac{k_\text{cat}}{k_\text{uncat}} = e^{\delta(\Delta G^\ddagger)/RT} \approx 10^{8.8}$$

Transition state analogs are stable molecules that mimic the geometry and charge distribution of the transition state. They bind to enzymes with extraordinary affinity (often $K_d \sim 10^{-13}$ M) and serve as potent inhibitors. Many drugs are designed as transition state analogs.

Catalytic Mechanisms

Enzymes employ several fundamental chemical strategies to accelerate reactions. Most enzymes use a combination of these mechanisms simultaneously.

1. Acid-Base Catalysis

In general acid-base catalysis, amino acid side chains donate or accept protons during the reaction. This is distinct from specific acid-base catalysis, which involves only $\text{H}^+$ or $\text{OH}^-$ from water. Common residues involved include His (p$K_a \approx 6$), Glu/Asp, Lys, and Cys. The rate depends on the concentration of the proton-donor or -acceptor amino acid side chain:

$$v = k[\text{HA}][\text{S}] \quad \text{or} \quad v = k[\text{B}][\text{S}]$$

2. Covalent Catalysis

The enzyme forms a transient covalent bond with the substrate. A nucleophilic group on the enzyme (typically Ser-OH, Cys-SH, His-imidazole, or Lys-$\varepsilon$-NH$_2$) attacks an electrophilic center on the substrate, forming a covalent intermediate that is subsequently hydrolyzed. This lowers $\Delta G^\ddagger$ by breaking the reaction into two steps, each with a lower activation barrier than the single uncatalyzed step.

3. Metal Ion Catalysis

Metal ions ($\text{Zn}^{2+}$, $\text{Mg}^{2+}$, $\text{Fe}^{2+}/\text{Fe}^{3+}$, $\text{Mn}^{2+}$) contribute to catalysis in several ways:

  • Electrostatic stabilization of negative charges in the transition state
  • Generation of nucleophilic hydroxide ions from water at neutral pH
  • Redox chemistry via reversible changes in oxidation state (e.g., cytochrome P450)
  • Orientation of substrates for optimal orbital overlap

4. Proximity and Orientation Effects

By binding substrates in a precisely defined orientation, enzymes achieve enormous rate enhancements through the effective molarity concept. When two reacting groups are held in close proximity and proper orientation within the active site, the effective concentration of one reactant relative to the other can be extraordinarily high:

$$\text{Effective molarity} = \frac{k_\text{intra} \, (\text{s}^{-1})}{k_\text{inter} \, (\text{M}^{-1}\text{s}^{-1})} \sim 10^3 \text{ to } 10^8 \text{ M}$$

This means the enzyme concentrates reactants to effective concentrations far exceeding what is physically achievable in solution.

The Active Site

The active site is a three-dimensional cleft or pocket on the enzyme surface where substrate binding and catalysis occur. Although the active site typically comprises only a small fraction of the total enzyme volume (often just 10-20 amino acid residues), it is responsible for the enzyme's catalytic power and specificity.

Key Principle: Complementarity to the Transition State

Linus Pauling (1946) proposed the foundational insight of enzyme catalysis: the active site is complementary to the transition state, not the substrate. If the enzyme bound the substrate most tightly, it would stabilize the ground state and actually increase the activation barrier.

$$\Delta G_\text{binding}^\ddagger > \Delta G_\text{binding}^{\text{ES}} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \text{Transition state binds more tightly}$$

Lock-and-Key vs. Induced Fit

Emil Fischer (1894) proposed the lock-and-key model: the enzyme active site has a rigid, pre-formed shape perfectly complementary to the substrate. While this explains specificity, it fails to account for many experimental observations.

Daniel Koshland (1958) proposed the induced fit model: substrate binding induces conformational changes in the enzyme that optimize the active site geometry for catalysis. This model explains why some substrates that structurally resemble the true substrate are not catalyzed -- they cannot induce the correct conformational change.

Binding Energy Drives Catalysis

The free energy of binding ($\Delta G_\text{bind}$) released upon formation of the enzyme-substrate complex is not merely for recognition. A portion of this binding energy is used to distort the substrate toward the transition state geometry and to compensate for the entropic cost of bringing reactants together:

$$\Delta G^\ddagger_\text{cat} = \Delta G^\ddagger_\text{uncat} + \Delta G_\text{bind}^\ddagger$$

Since $\Delta G_\text{bind}^\ddagger < 0$, the catalyzed activation barrier is lower than the uncatalyzed one.

Serine Proteases: A Case Study

The serine proteases are among the best-characterized enzyme families and serve as a paradigm for understanding enzyme catalysis. The family includes chymotrypsin (cleaves after large hydrophobic residues), trypsin (cleaves after Arg and Lys), and elastase (cleaves after small residues like Ala, Gly, Ser). Despite their different specificities, they share an identical catalytic mechanism.

The Catalytic Triad

The active site contains three essential residues that work in concert: Ser195, His57, and Asp102 (chymotrypsin numbering). These residues form a hydrogen-bonded network called the charge relay system:

$$\text{Asp}^{102}\text{---H--N} \underset{\displaystyle|}{\overset{\displaystyle|}{\text{His}^{57}}} \text{N--H---O-}\text{Ser}^{195}$$

Asp102 orients and polarizes His57, which in turn deprotonates Ser195, making its hydroxyl oxygen an exceptionally powerful nucleophile.

Catalytic Mechanism (Step by Step)

Step 1 -- Nucleophilic Attack: The activated Ser195 oxygen attacks the carbonyl carbon of the peptide bond, forming a tetrahedral intermediate. The negative charge on the former carbonyl oxygen is stabilized by the oxyanion hole (backbone NH groups of Gly193 and Ser195).
Step 2 -- Acyl-Enzyme Formation: The tetrahedral intermediate collapses. The peptide bond breaks, releasing the C-terminal fragment (the amine leaving group). The N-terminal portion remains covalently bound to Ser195 as the acyl-enzyme intermediate.
Step 3 -- Deacylation: A water molecule, activated by His57, attacks the acyl-enzyme intermediate, forming a second tetrahedral intermediate. This collapses to release the N-terminal product and regenerate the free enzyme.

The Oxyanion Hole

The oxyanion hole is a preformed binding site that stabilizes the negatively charged oxygen of the tetrahedral intermediate through two hydrogen bonds from backbone NH groups. This stabilization lowers$\Delta G^\ddagger$ by approximately 40-50 kJ/mol. Site-directed mutagenesis experiments confirm that disruption of the oxyanion hole reduces catalytic efficiency by $10^3$-$10^4$ fold.

Cofactors and Coenzymes

Many enzymes require additional non-protein chemical groups for activity. These are broadly classified as cofactors (inorganic metal ions) and coenzymes (organic molecules, often derived from vitamins). A holoenzyme is the complete catalytically active form (apoenzyme + cofactor/coenzyme), while the apoenzyme is the protein portion alone.

Metal Ion Cofactors

Approximately one-third of all enzymes require metal ions. Tightly bound metals are called metalloenzymes; loosely associated metals are metal-activated enzymes.

Metal IonExample EnzymeFunction
$\text{Zn}^{2+}$Carbonic anhydrase, carboxypeptidaseLewis acid catalysis, structural
$\text{Fe}^{2+}/\text{Fe}^{3+}$Cytochrome oxidase, catalaseElectron transfer, redox
$\text{Cu}^{2+}$Cytochrome oxidase, superoxide dismutaseElectron transfer
$\text{Mn}^{2+}$Arginase, superoxide dismutaseLewis acid, structural
$\text{Mg}^{2+}$Hexokinase, DNA polymerasePhosphoryl transfer, structural

Organic Coenzymes

Coenzymes act as transient carriers of specific functional groups. They may be tightly bound (prosthetic groups) or loosely associated (cosubstrates). Most water-soluble vitamins serve as coenzyme precursors.

CoenzymeVitamin PrecursorGroup TransferredKey Reaction
$\text{NAD}^+/\text{NADH}$Niacin (B3)Hydride ion ($\text{H}^-$)Oxidation-reduction
$\text{FAD}/\text{FADH}_2$Riboflavin (B2)Electrons + H$^+$Oxidation-reduction
Coenzyme A (CoA-SH)Pantothenate (B5)Acyl groupsAcyl transfer
TPPThiamine (B1)AldehydesDecarboxylation
PLPPyridoxine (B6)Amino groupsTransamination
BiotinBiotin (B7)$\text{CO}_2$Carboxylation
Tetrahydrofolate (THF)Folate (B9)One-carbon unitsC1 transfer
CobalaminB12H atoms, alkyl groupsIsomerization, methyl transfer

$\text{NAD}^+$ / NADH: The Universal Electron Carrier

$\text{NAD}^+$ accepts a hydride ion ($\text{H}^-$, i.e., two electrons and one proton) from the substrate, becoming reduced to NADH. The nicotinamide ring is the reactive center:

$$\text{NAD}^+ + 2\text{e}^- + \text{H}^+ \longrightarrow \text{NADH}$$

The standard reduction potential is $E^{\circ\prime} = -0.32$ V, making NADH a strong reducing agent. The ratio $[\text{NAD}^+]/[\text{NADH}]$ in the cytoplasm is typically ~700, favoring oxidation, while in mitochondria the ratio is lower (~8), reflecting the reducing environment.

Key Concepts

Enzyme Fundamentals

  • Enzymes lower $\Delta G^\ddagger$, not $\Delta G$
  • Rate enhancement: $10^6$ to $10^{17}$ fold
  • Six EC classes based on reaction type
  • Most enzymes are proteins; ribozymes are RNA

Transition State Theory

  • Eyring: $k = (k_BT/h)\,e^{-\Delta G^\ddagger/RT}$
  • Enzymes stabilize transition state, not substrate
  • Transition state analogs are potent inhibitors
  • $\Delta G^\ddagger = \Delta H^\ddagger - T\Delta S^\ddagger$

Catalytic Strategies

  • Acid-base catalysis (proton transfer)
  • Covalent catalysis (nucleophilic attack)
  • Metal ion catalysis (Lewis acid, redox)
  • Proximity & orientation (effective molarity)

Active Site & Serine Proteases

  • Induced fit model (Koshland, 1958)
  • Catalytic triad: Ser195-His57-Asp102
  • Oxyanion hole stabilizes tetrahedral intermediate
  • Binding energy drives catalysis

Cofactors & Coenzymes

  • Metal cofactors: $\text{Zn}^{2+}$, $\text{Fe}^{2+/3+}$, $\text{Mg}^{2+}$, $\text{Cu}^{2+}$, $\text{Mn}^{2+}$
  • $\text{NAD}^+$/NADH and $\text{FAD}$/$\text{FADH}_2$: electron carriers from B-vitamins
  • Coenzyme A: acyl group transfer; PLP: transamination; TPP: decarboxylation
  • Holoenzyme = apoenzyme + cofactor(s)