Phase Shifts and Resonances
Calculating phase shifts, low-energy scattering, Breit-Wigner resonances, and the Ramsauer-Townsend effect
Calculating Phase Shifts: Boundary Matching
The phase shifts are determined by solving the radial Schrodinger equation inside the potential region and matching to the asymptotic free-particle solution at the boundary. For a potential that vanishes for $r > a$, the solution in the exterior region is a linear combination of spherical Bessel and Neumann functions:
The matching conditions at $r = a$ require continuity of $u_\ell$and $u_\ell'$. Defining the logarithmic derivative:
the phase shift is determined by matching logarithmic derivatives across the boundary:
Here primes denote derivatives with respect to the argument. The interior logarithmic derivative $\gamma_\ell$ is obtained by integrating the radial equation from $r = 0$ to $r = a$.
Hard Sphere Scattering
The simplest example is the hard sphere: $V = \infty$ for $r < a$and $V = 0$ for $r > a$. The boundary condition is$u_\ell(a) = 0$, which gives:
For low energies ($ka \ll 1$), using the small-argument expansions of the spherical Bessel functions:
we find that the phase shifts vanish rapidly with increasing $\ell$:
This confirms the dominance of s-wave ($\ell = 0$) scattering at low energy. For the hard sphere specifically: $\delta_0 \approx -ka$, so the scattering length is $a_s = a$ and $\sigma = 4\pi a^2$.
Low-Energy Limit: s-Wave Dominance
When the de Broglie wavelength is much larger than the range of the potential ($ka \ll 1$), the centrifugal barrier $\sim \ell(\ell+1)/r^2$prevents higher partial waves from reaching the scattering center. Only the s-wave ($\ell = 0$) contributes significantly:
The scattering is isotropic (independent of angle) since $P_0(\cos\theta) = 1$.
Scattering Length
The scattering length $a$ is defined as the low-energy limit of the phase shift:
The low-energy cross section is:
The sign of the scattering length carries physical meaning:
- $a > 0$: effectively repulsive interaction (e.g., hard sphere gives $a = R$)
- $a < 0$: effectively attractive interaction (e.g., neutron-proton singlet state)
- $|a| \to \infty$: near a zero-energy bound state or virtual state (unitarity limit)
Effective Range Expansion
The low-energy behavior of the s-wave phase shift is captured systematically by the effective range expansion:
Here $a$ is the scattering length and $r_0$ is the effective range, which characterizes the spatial extent of the potential. This expansion is remarkably universalβit depends on only two parameters regardless of the detailed shape of $V(r)$.
For the hard sphere of radius $R$: $a = R$ and $r_0 = 2R/3$. For nucleon-nucleon scattering, measured values are $a \approx -23.7$ fm (singlet) and $a \approx 5.4$ fm (triplet), with $r_0 \approx 2.7$ fm for both.
Breit-Wigner Resonances
A scattering resonance occurs when a phase shift passes rapidly through$\pi/2$ (or $\pi/2 + n\pi$) as the energy increases. Near a resonance at energy $E_r$, the phase shift has the characteristic form:
where $\Gamma$ is the resonance width and$\delta_\ell^{(\text{bg})}$ is a slowly varying background phase. The partial wave cross section near a resonance takes the Breit-Wigner form:
This is a Lorentzian peak centered at $E = E_r$ with full width at half maximum$\Gamma$. At the peak ($E = E_r$), the cross section reaches the unitarity limit $4\pi(2\ell+1)/k^2$.
Physical Interpretation of Resonances
- A resonance corresponds to a quasi-bound state trapped behind the centrifugal + potential barrier
- The particle temporarily orbits within the potential before tunneling back out
- The lifetime of the quasi-bound state is $\tau = \hbar/\Gamma$
- Narrow resonances ($\Gamma \ll E_r$) correspond to long-lived states
- Wide resonances ($\Gamma \sim E_r$) are short-lived and may overlap with other features
The Ramsauer-Townsend Effect
The Ramsauer-Townsend effect is a striking quantum phenomenon in which the scattering cross section drops to nearly zero at a specific energy. It occurs when the s-wave phase shift passes through $\delta_0 = n\pi$ (integer $n$), making $\sin^2\delta_0 = 0$.
If higher partial waves are negligible (low energy), the total cross section vanishes:
The incoming wave passes through the potential region with its phase shifted by exactly a multiple of $\pi$, emerging as if no scattering occurred. This is partial transparencyβa purely quantum effect with no classical analog.
Experimental Observations
- Observed in electron scattering from noble gas atoms (Ar, Kr, Xe)
- Cross section minimum at electron energies around 0.7 eV for argon
- Not observed in He or Ne (their potentials are too shallow for $\delta_0$ to reach $\pi$)
- Requires the attractive potential to be just strong enough to produce a near-integer multiple of $\pi$ phase shift
Square Well Phase Shifts
For the finite square well $V = -V_0$ for $r < a$, zero otherwise, the interior wave number is $k' = \sqrt{k^2 + 2mV_0/\hbar^2}$. Matching the interior and exterior solutions at $r = a$ gives the phase shifts:
For the s-wave ($\ell = 0$), this simplifies to:
Key features:
- Resonances appear when $\delta_\ell$ passes through $\pi/2$, corresponding to quasi-bound states in the well
- Negative scattering length indicates a virtual bound state (pole of the S-matrix on the negative imaginary $k$-axis)
- Bound states exist when $\delta_\ell(k=0) = n\pi$ with $n \geq 1$ (Levinson's theorem)
Shape Resonances vs. Feshbach Resonances
There are two distinct types of resonances in quantum scattering:
Types of Resonances
- Shape (or potential) resonances: arise from the shape of the effective potential barrier (centrifugal + actual potential). A particle tunnels through the barrier, is temporarily trapped, and tunnels back out. These occur for $\ell \geq 1$even in simple single-channel problems.
- Feshbach resonances: arise from coupling between channels. A bound state in a closed channel becomes a resonance when embedded in the continuum of an open channel. These are crucial in cold atom physics for tuning interactions.
The Breit-Wigner formula applies to both types near an isolated resonance. The width$\Gamma$ has a characteristic energy dependence:
Higher partial wave resonances are inherently narrower at low energy because the centrifugal barrier suppresses tunneling.