Geochemistry
Thermodynamics of mineral equilibria, element classification, and rare earth elements
4.1 Thermodynamics of Mineral Equilibria
Geochemistry applies chemical thermodynamics to understand which minerals are stable under given conditions of temperature, pressure, and composition. The fundamental criterion for equilibrium is minimization of the Gibbs free energy.
Derivation 1: Gibbs Free Energy and Mineral Stability
The Gibbs free energy of a reaction is:
where $\Delta H$ is enthalpy change and $\Delta S$ is entropy change. At constant temperature and pressure, a reaction proceeds spontaneously when $\Delta G < 0$. The pressure and temperature dependence of $\Delta G$ is:
For solids at moderate pressures, the volume term $\Delta V \Delta P$ is often small. The equilibrium boundary in P-T space is found by setting $\Delta G = 0$. The Clausius-Clapeyron equation gives the slope:
For example, the diamond-graphite transition has a positive Clapeyron slope because diamond has smaller volume ($\Delta V < 0$ for graphite$\rightarrow$diamond) and lower entropy ($\Delta S < 0$), so $dP/dT > 0$. Diamond is stable at high P (above ~4 GPa at 1000$°$C).
Historical Context
J. Willard Gibbs (1876-1878) established the thermodynamic framework. Norman Bowen (1928) applied it to igneous petrology with his reaction series. H.J. Greenwood, J.B. Thompson, and others developed the thermodynamic databases used in modern phase equilibrium software (THERMOCALC, Perple_X).
4.2 Chemical Potential and Activity
Derivation 2: The Equilibrium Constant from Chemical Potentials
For a reaction involving species with chemical potentials $\mu_i$, equilibrium requires:
where $\nu_i$ are stoichiometric coefficients (positive for products, negative for reactants). The chemical potential of component $i$ in a solution is:
where $a_i$ is the thermodynamic activity. Substituting into the equilibrium condition:
This is the fundamental relationship between the standard Gibbs energy change and the equilibrium constant $K$. The van't Hoff equation gives the temperature dependence:
For endothermic reactions ($\Delta H^0 > 0$), $K$ increases with temperature, favoring products at higher T.
4.3 Goldschmidt Classification
Derivation 3: Partition Coefficients and Element Distribution
Victor Goldschmidt (1937) classified elements into four groups based on their geochemical affinity during planetary differentiation:
- Lithophile (rock-loving): Prefer silicate/oxide phases. Si, Al, Ca, Na, K, Mg, Ti, Mn, Cr, U, Th, REE
- Siderophile (iron-loving): Prefer metallic iron. Fe, Co, Ni, Pt, Pd, Au, Re, Os, Ir, W, Mo
- Chalcophile (sulfide-loving): Prefer sulfide phases. Cu, Zn, Pb, Ag, As, Sb, Bi, Cd, Hg
- Atmophile (atmosphere-loving): Concentrated in gas phase. N, noble gases, C (partially), H
The distribution of an element between two phases is quantified by the partition (distribution) coefficient:
If $D \gg 1$, the element is compatible (concentrated in the solid); if $D \ll 1$, it is incompatible (concentrated in the melt). The bulk partition coefficient for a multi-phase assemblage is the weighted average:
where $X_j$ is the weight fraction and $D_j$ is the partition coefficient for mineral phase $j$. During fractional crystallization, the concentration in the residual melt follows:
where $F$ is the fraction of melt remaining. This is the Rayleigh fractionation equation, which explains why incompatible elements (e.g., K, Rb, U, Th) become enriched in evolved melts and ultimately in the continental crust.
4.4 Rare Earth Element Geochemistry
Derivation 4: REE Patterns from Partial Melting
The rare earth elements (La through Lu) have smoothly varying ionic radii and uniformly $3+$ charge (except Ce$^{4+}$ and Eu$^{2+}$). Their concentrations normalized to chondritic meteorite values reveal diagnostic patterns. For batch (equilibrium) partial melting:
where $D_0$ is the bulk partition coefficient and $F$ is the melt fraction. Since light REE (LREE: La, Ce, Nd) are more incompatible than heavy REE (HREE: Er, Yb, Lu), partial melts of the mantle are LREE-enriched relative to chondrites.
The Eu anomaly ($\text{Eu}/\text{Eu}^* = \text{Eu}_N / \sqrt{\text{Sm}_N \times \text{Gd}_N}$) is diagnostic: negative anomalies indicate plagioclase fractionation (Eu$^{2+}$substitutes for Ca$^{2+}$ in plagioclase), characteristic of evolved continental crust.
Derivation 5: The Lanthanide Contraction and Ionic Radii
The systematic decrease in ionic radius across the lanthanide series arises from imperfect shielding of $4f$ electrons. As nuclear charge increases from La ($Z = 57$) to Lu ($Z = 71$), each added $4f$ electron provides incomplete shielding of the increasing nuclear charge, resulting in a contraction:
with $r_{\text{La}^{3+}} = 1.16$ angstrom and $r_{\text{Lu}^{3+}} = 0.977$ angstrom (Shannon, 1976). This smooth variation means that minerals preferentially incorporate either LREE (large sites: apatite, monazite) or HREE (small sites: garnet, zircon), producing the characteristic REE patterns used in petrogenetic modeling.
4.5 Applications: Phase Diagrams and Geothermobarometry
Geothermobarometry uses the temperature and pressure dependence of mineral equilibria to determine the P-T conditions of rock formation. The garnet-biotite Fe-Mg exchange thermometer is based on:
which is temperature-dependent: $\ln K_D = A/T + B$. Similarly, the Al content of orthopyroxene coexisting with garnet is pressure-sensitive, providing a barometer. Together, thermobarometry constrains the P-T paths of metamorphic rocks, revealing burial, exhumation, and tectonic processes.
Modern Computational Petrology
Software packages like THERMOCALC (Powell and Holland), Perple_X (Connolly), and MELTS (Ghiorso and Sack) compute phase equilibria from internally consistent thermodynamic databases. Pseudosections (P-T phase diagrams calculated for a specific bulk composition) show the stable mineral assemblage at each point in P-T space, enabling direct comparison with observed mineral assemblages.
The concept of chemical potential diagrams extends phase diagrams to open systems. For example, T-$f$O$_2$ diagrams show the stability of iron-bearing minerals as a function of temperature and oxygen fugacity, critical for understanding ore formation and metamorphic redox reactions. Activity-activity diagrams for aqueous systems predict mineral stability in weathering and hydrothermal environments.
The trace element and isotopic composition of zircon (ZrSiO$_4$) has revolutionized geochemistry. Zircon's chemical and physical robustness preserves records of crystallization age (U-Pb), temperature (Ti-in-zircon thermometer: $T(°C) = -4800/[\log(\text{Ti/ppm}) - 5.711] - 273$), source composition ($\varepsilon_{\text{Hf}}$), and oxygen isotopes ($\delta^{18}$O). Detrital zircon studies have reconstructed the growth history of the continental crust back to 4.37 Ga.
4.6 Multi-Element Diagrams and Mantle Reservoirs
Extended trace element diagrams (spider diagrams) plot mantle-normalized concentrations of many elements ordered by increasing incompatibility. Different tectonic settings produce characteristic patterns:
- N-MORB: Flat to LREE-depleted, reflecting the depleted mantle source
- E-MORB and OIB: LREE-enriched with smooth patterns, from enriched mantle plumes
- Island arc basalt: Enriched in LILE (K, Rb, Ba, Sr) with Nb-Ta negative anomalies, due to slab fluid addition
- Continental flood basalt: Variable, often with crustal contamination signatures
The mantle is geochemically heterogeneous, comprising several end-member reservoirs identified by radiogenic isotopes: DMM (Depleted MORB Mantle), EM1 and EM2 (Enriched Mantle, from recycled sediments or lower continental lithosphere), HIMU (High-$\mu$, from recycled oceanic crust), and FOZO (focal zone of mantle plumes). These reservoirs reflect 4.5 Gyr of plate tectonic recycling and mantle mixing.
The Continental Crust Paradox
The continental crust has an average composition close to andesite ($\sim$60% SiO$_2$), yet it is ultimately derived from basaltic melts of the mantle. Rudnick and Gao (2003) proposed that the crust differentiates through intracrustal melting and delamination of dense mafic residues. The heat-producing elements (U, Th, K) are strongly enriched in the upper crust, with $\sim$40% of Earth's total heat production concentrated in just 0.6% of its mass.
Gibbs Phase Rule in Petrology
The phase rule constrains the number of degrees of freedom $F$ in a system:
where $C$ is the number of components and $P$ is the number of phases. In a one-component system (e.g., SiO$_2$), two phases coexist along a univariant line (F=1), and three phases at an invariant point (F=0). The Al$_2$SiO$_5$ system (kyanite-sillimanite-andalusite) has a triple point at approximately 500$°$C and 3.8 kbar, used as a key constraint in metamorphic petrology.
Computational Lab: Geochemistry
Thermodynamics, REE Patterns, and Fractional Crystallization
PythonClick Run to execute the Python code
Code will be executed with Python 3 on the server
Geothermobarometry and Mineral Stability Calculations
PythonClick Run to execute the Python code
Code will be executed with Python 3 on the server